Other ACC Info

Animal Care Committee Ethical Scenario #1

Ethics Main Page

Scenario Set-Up

You are a first year post-doc working in Dr. Eric McGarrity's laboratory who is doing some ground-breaking work in immunology.  You felt honored to get a position in the laboratory- it was very competitive.  The research protocol you are working with involves cats and innovative work.

The Situation

It is early on a Saturday (8am) when you come in to do your work.  Dr. McGarrity walks into the laboratory and says that the cats have to have timed blood draws (10 ml each) at 2:00 and 4:00pm and make to sure this happens because all the work for the past 6 months "will be worthless" if it doesn't happen.  You start getting everything ready to perform the blood work on the cats.

The Problem

You are reviewing the protocol and realize that the protocol doesn't have approval to draw the blood from the cats.  You find Dr. McGarrity in his office and explain this and he states that this isn't a problem; because he has this approval on other protocols, it is a minor oversight at worst.  He tells you to just do the blood draws.

What do you do?

As a twist...

You are the attending veterinarian and happen to be in the facility because of another issue and hear your vet techs discussing the blood draws (they found it out somehow).  You go up and talk with Dr. McGarrity about this issue.  As you review all of his current, IACUC-approved protocols, it is clear that he does not have approval to perform 2 10-ml timed blood draws on cats.

What do you do?

As a twist...

You are the chair of the IACUC and the PI called you to inform you that he needed to take the timed blood samples in order to not waste these animals and 6 months worth of work and "just realized' that he does not have approval to perform this procedure on his cats. 

What do you do?